So the story that the buyers of our house told us was that the house was originally the rectory for the big Catholic church in our town, about a half mile away.
I have been trying to figure out if this is true, without going to the church and asking them. I am a little concerned that someone might want to landmark it or something crazy like that. Keeping a low profile in my 'research' seems like an appropriate thing to do.
A month or so ago one of the daughters that grew up in the house came by and brought us a photo of the house before it was moved. She told me the street that it was on and I walked by there with Layla a couple of weeks ago. There is a house immediately across the street from where I think our house was. It's for sale and has a sign that says IT was the original church rectory.
After that I was a little perplexed. So I have been hunting for photos online and found this website:
http://www.historicaerials.com/It's fantastic. I can see my house before and after the move. Don't get crazy, we are talking about aerial photos from 1938. It's not Google Earth. But, I am pretty sure I can see where my house was and that they needed to move it in order to make room for the new church.
In the 1938 photos it is on the church property and in 1951 (the next available photo) it is in its current location. This fits with the timeline we figured. I found one timeline that says the new church school was opened in 1945. This seems to work with the timeline as well although I couldn't determine exactly when the new church was built. I guess there must be a plaque or something over there I could check on.
Below is the photo that she gave us and a couple of the house now. It appears that this is the Master Bedroom wall, which was the front room of the house. But our house is considerably longer than this, so again, I really don't know what to make of it. It looks like the east and west end of our house, with the middle section plopped in. Weird!



Also, in the 1938 photos, that OTHER house isn't there. So, I suspect it was the rectory after our house was. Or maybe our house wasn't the rectory? The daughter said that her in-laws were married there (in the Master Bedroom (previously the front room)). Sort of odd to learn that your in-laws were married in your parents' bedroom, but there you have it.
If I can figure anything else out, I'll be sure to tell you!